Confessions of a Halloween-Hiding, Holiday-Hater: Thoughts on the Christian Rejection of Halloween

Watching a movie and eating pizza, my brother—who was in charge of being the lookout—made the signal that someone was walking up our driveway and was headed toward the door. I quickly clicked off the television, turned off the porch light, and we both hid behind the couch. Our noses poked out over the edge of the back of the couch as we strained to see through the dark widow without being noticed. We could hear the giggling kids as they shuffled about at our doorstep. Their plastic candy-filled bags were ready to be filled to the brim with our generous portions of snickers, gummy worms, and nerds.

Ding-dong.

….

Ding-dong. Ding-dong.

….

KNOCK-KNOCK-KNOCK

We stood stooped still as statues, daring not to breathe a word or move lest our cover be blown. We were supposed to pretend that we weren’t home. We could hear the sighs and grumblings of the small troop of kids as they walked away from our door empty-handed. But there was no time to be disappointed. There were thousands of houses out there ready to hand-out candy by the fist-full.

And while we breathed a sigh of relief, part of my heart wished to burst out the door and chase after the kids yelling “take me with you!”

My younger brother and I could not have been older than eight.

We were not allowed to celebrate the evil, devil-worshiping holiday known as Halloween.

My parents had only the best intentions. We were allowed to trick-or-treat a few years before. The candy flowed like wine! Our bags spilled over in abundance. But our parents shut-off the candy flow one fateful year when a man dressed as the devil told my little brother than he would take his soul to hell. My parents were less than ecstatic, as one would guess.

Their response was to ban Halloween.

We participated in the local church’s “Fall Festival,” but it was a lousy substitute. There was not much candy to speak of except the ghetto grabs that were purchased in bulk from Wal-Mart or some other such place.

Eventually we just started staying home.

And over the years, I forgot my distaste with my parents’ decision and began to embrace it—and look down on any other Christian who would not do the same.

This was an evil, pagan holiday rooted in witchcraft and sorcery. How could I participate in such a clearly evil night? From the images on the jack-o-lantern’s face to the cheesy pumpkin and black cat posters what are hung in home, all were evil images inspired by the devil.

I was “educated” by watching quasi-Christian documentaries like “The Pagan Invasion”—detailed videos on the pagan roots and takeover of our culture through holidays like Halloween.

It was not until much later in my life that I embraced Halloween as an innocent and fun night for kids to dress up, get candy, and have fun.

There is no denying that Halloween has its roots in pagan practices—but so does every holiday—Christmas and Easter being the most prominent of these. Regardless, a fundamental shift in thinking and approach to culture needs to be taken—one which I had realized only a few short years ago.

Should the follower of Christ only celebrate Christian holidays and embrace only Christian images and Christian culture? If so, they might have a hard time working and living in a world that truly has nothing to do with Christ.

The lack of Christ directly and publicly involved in activities does not make it worthless. One can go to the movies and enjoy. One can listen to music. One can skate, work, sleep, exercise, or eat and enjoy the life and creation that God has made. This is worship. This is God honoring. So too is it honoring to God to trick-or-treat, dress-up, carve pumpkins, and eat lots of candy.

It is his creation. And it is good.

But beyond this, the question is—would Christ hit the lights, hiding behind the back of a couch waiting for the evil trick-or-treaters to move on to the next house? Or would he open the door joyfully and give out the best candy possible?

What do you think?

THEOLOGY21 is a co-op of authors dedicated to renovating theology for a new generation, taking the ancient truths of scripture and theology and speaking to the post-Christian culture of the 21st century. To keep up-to-date on all things THEOLOGY21, Give our Facebook page a “like”, follow our twitter page, add yourself to our email list, or subscribe to our feed!
 
__________________________________________________

  • http://nolonger1st.blogspot.com mbcshawn

    Best Candy for sure… Then He would ask if He could come along and hang out at there House… But I think He would do this with only one person… The one that be off by themselves (in a tree lets say)… It seems to me that Christ engaged in the culture of his time (not sining). He keep the traditions of the times… Why wouldnt He get involved in a tradition that puts you face to face with people… He wouldnt be the one that hands out the "1,000,000 dollar" track (please dont ever do this)… He would be the one that would say, "Take your pick… but remember candy leaves you empty and wanting more but I Am the One that can fill you forever" or some cool parable to go with it.

    Anyway…. Jon… Great Post

    • Jonathandkeck

      You are so right! I could totally see Jesus saying some incredible parables while handing out candy. The question in my mind is, if Jesus were to dress-up for Halloween, what would he dress as?

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Confessions of a Halloween-Hiding, Holiday-Hater: Thoughts on the Christian Rejection of Halloween : Jonathan Daniel Keck -- Topsy.com

  • pastor paul

    this year we had a halloween fest at church. not harvest fest. we put on a haunted hayride that just never stopped, the kids just kept comming and so did the screams, laughter and fun. i (the pastor) had a gorilla suit and jumped out of the bushes scaring the pee outta kids and we had one of the funnest church events ever. i think jesus would of had a blast.

    • Jonathandkeck

      Awesome Paul! That's the sort of church that I would want to attend and, I think, the sort that Jesus wants us to create and be. Thanks for sharing!

  • Alex S.

    I can't believe those videos are still around. I watched it with my home group about two years ago. Couldn't focus. I giggled like a little girl throughout the whole thing; the retro fashion and hair-dos were just too much for me to stay still. Maybe the subliminals jacked with my head, but . . . I've always been indifferent about Holloween. Most my friends are haters, not really, but too focused on the evil aspects I think. Witches and sorcery ain't no joke, man. That stuff is for real, like you mentioned in your witch post. But it's like everything else, you can't throw out the good candy with the bad candy. That would just be wrong.

    Similar story though. My sister and I were strictly prohibited to answer the door on Holloween while the rents were out working. They turned off the porch lights for us so nobody would approach. There was always the brave kid who rolled up, and something in me couldn't let him leave without me slipping him a choice mini candy bar (that I had collected at school) like it was a drug deal or something. I wanted to be him. We were so relieved when my Uncle would show up with a bag o' lolipops from wal-mart, not for the candy, but because it was like we had been rescued from an all-night stake out. We were happy again.

    My parents finally buckled one year and let me tag along in the back of my friend's dad's pick-up. They hit up River Oaks and Bellaire, where they served nothing but da good stuff. I was "that one kid." No costume. Plastic Fiesta (local grocery store) bag and pockets full of enough sugar to put me in a coma.

    Anywayz, I've never dressed up. Why start now? Don't really care for it. Although going as a slice of pizza would be cool. When I have kids they'll have fun and I'll live vicariously through them. In the meantime, I'll give out the best candy I can buy. Thanks for posting this, Jon. It was nice to reflect back on the years. Enjoy your weekend.

    • Jonathandkeck

      Thanks for sharing your Halloween memories Alex! It sounds like we had similar experiences. I now try to give my daughter the best possible Halloweens and help create the best Halloween/Harvest festival possible at the church I work at. We rent an In-N-Out Burger truck, popcorn, cotton candy machine, jumpers, dunktanks, etc. And of course the best candy possible. I believe it is the job of the church and a family to provide the most safe and fun night possible on Halloween for our communities and our children. Thank's for sharing!

      • AlexSantxo

        In-n-Out burgers! Love it. That's what it's about, create inviting environments for opportunities to serve and share the gospel. Have fun!

    • Sophia

      ha, really liked what you said about feeling like you were making some kind of drug deal with candy. it's important to note that God doesn't want us to feel ashamed of having fun or even interacting with someone else over candy! the way some Chrisitans choose to hide and close their doors to trick-o-treaters is really representative of how they treat non-Christians everyday! They hide, they don't converse, they close their eyes to reality and save themselves (or so they think) with their own egos.

      • AlexSantxo

        Well said! And no trick-or-treaters in sight just yet. But when they show up I'm ready to lavish them with all the Kit Kats they can handle. No shame in my game!